TravelGuides – ‘A tragic and wasted opportunity’: Australia’s inglorious exit from Afghanistan | Australian foreign policy


JourneyGuides – ‘A tragic and wasted opportunity’: Australia’s inglorious exit from Afghanistan | Australian foreign policy

During the 20 years through which Australia was ensnared in an unwinnable conflict after trailing the US into Afghanistan, a succession of our political leaders spoke reassuringly about how they’d not desert the Afghans.


“We will not abandon Afghanistan,” the then prime minister Julia Gillard declared in 2011.


Her successor, Tony Abbott, stated we must not ever “cut and run”.

And but, with no formal announcement, Australia lastly retreated from Afghanistan in mid-June with barely a whimper, pulling out the final of its 80 navy personnel forward of America’s ultimate troop withdrawal in late August.

The conflict has killed 41 Australian troops. Another 260 have been severely injured and a staggering 500 others have taken their very own lives since their deployment. Australia has invested greater than $10bn in a conflict that has additionally maybe irreparably broken the status of the elite Special Air Service amid allegations of conflict crimes in opposition to essentially the most adorned residing Australian soldier, Ben Roberts-Smith (which he strenuously denies), amongst others.

Australia’s Afghanistan journey is ending ingloriously.

The Taliban are resurgent, capturing Afghan National Army bases and threatening many who labored with the US, its allies and Nato – together with a whole lot of interpreters who helped Australian forces. The divided, corruption-plagued US-backed central authorities is unable to correctly defend itself with its fragmented, ailing-disciplined military. Fear of an unsure future grips Afghanistan.

The conclusion that Australia has deserted Afghanistan on the exiting coat tails of America appears inescapable.

The optics are pitiful. Even shameful.

The remnants of the Australian navy departed unceremoniously, the one public signal that they had achieved so a news report two weeks later.

Aspects of the US withdrawal have been extra ignominious. Under cowl of evening this week US forces plunged their major working base at Bagram into darkness, shutting off the facility and abandoning the HQ to looters whereas slipping out the unlocked again door.

The Americans didn’t trouble to inform the Afghan commander who remained at Bagram he was now in cost.

‘We’ve deserted Afghanistan’

Retired Adm Chris Barrie was chief of the Australian Defence Force when Australia joined the American invasion of Taliban-governed Afghanistan in late 2001, after the September 11 al-Qaida assaults on the US.

“We’re leaving with indecent haste, as the Americans have,” Barrie says. “We followed the Americans in, and we were not going to stay an hour longer than they were. Really, we’ve abandoned Afghanistan. Twenty years of effort comes to almost nothing.”

The invasion had the categorical goal of ridding Afghanistan of al-Qaida terrorist bases and capturing or killing Osama bin Laden.

“It’s impoverished, and its infrastructure has been destroyed in a lot of places,” Barrie says. “A lot of breadwinners in a lot of families have been killed by a lot of coalition forces including ours. The Taliban is on the rise, and I am troubled by the unfolding events.

“But we weren’t really there to do any good for the people of Afghanistan, we were there to help the US. And it raises the question, what role did we have in the decision-making in Washington over the prosecution of the campaign?”

Quick Guide

How to get the newest information from Guardian Australia



Photograph: Tim Robberts/Stone RF

Thank you in your suggestions.

Maintaining the US alliance was at all times a major cause for Australia’s floor-ground participation within the Afghanistan invasion. The then prime minister John Howard, who was in Washington on September 11, almost immediately invoked the then 50-year-old Anzus treaty committing Australia, New Zealand and the US to help each other if any had been attacked.

Australia’s navy involvement had a number of phases: invasion and conflict-preventing in opposition to the Taliban and al-Qaida; close to full withdrawal in 2003 to take part within the Iraq invasion, throughout which the Taliban and varied terrorist organisations regrouped; extra fight operations till 2013, when Australia , scaled down and focused on civil works and mentoring Afghan forces.

In the “hearts and minds” rebuilding technique that Australia carried out (parallel at occasions to fight operations) a lot was made from the infrastructure – roads, hospitals and faculties – that will assist women obtain the training the Taliban had denied them.

They at the moment are prone to be destroyed by the Taliban, in the event that they haven’t already been.

‘These are lies. This is political spin’

If it has all, as Barrie says, come “to almost nothing”, a essential query shadows the previous 20 years: was it well worth the financial value and, extra importantly, the value in human life and enduring struggling?

It relies upon who you ask.

Yes, Australia’s navy commanders have at all times insisted.

“The sacrifice of our people is a sacrifice that is, I would say, worthy and it’s a terrible loss … But it is … about a contribution to Afghanistan, not a contribution to either the valley in which they might have died or, indeed, the province but ultimately about Afghanistan,” said the then chief of army, now defence force chief, Angus Campbell in 2016.

Asked final April if it had all been price the associated fee, Scott Morrison replied unequivocally: “Yes. Freedom is always worth it. Australians have always believed that.”

Hugh Poate’s 23-yr-previous military non-public son died in Afghanistan in August 2012 when a rogue member of the Afghan military opened fireplace, killing Robert Poate and two others.

“I just couldn’t believe Campbell said that,” Poate says. “I just kept re-reading it. I couldn’t understand how a person at such a high level of command in the Australian Defence Force given the number of deaths and the fact that nothing had been achieved … could make such a statement. And herein lies one of the problems with those commanders when they get to that level – they become pseudo-politicians rather than leaders of an armed force,” Poate says.

His latest ebook about Robert’s loss of life, Failures of Command, alleged senior navy incompetence and duplicity surrounding the killing of his son.

Of Morrison’s feedback, Poate says: “Again, I was aghast. It was bullshit. What he should have been referring to was the freedom of this country. And our country was not threatened. Again, this is just some way of trying to justify the loss of 41 lives in Afghanistan, the ruining of 261 [through serious injury] and some 500 who’ve since taken their own lives … these are lies. This is political spin.”

Poate and Barrie every say the primary part of anti-terrorist operations in Afghanistan was profitable.

Poate says: “The reason we went to war was clearly articulated at the time by John Howard – to destroy the al-Qaida training camps and to kill or capture Osama bin Laden. They were the objectives. They were both achieved by 2011. After the final objective, Australia was still there and we lost another 18 men. Including our son.”

‘Were we ever there?’

The former police officer and conflict crimes investigator David Savage was severely disabled and almost killed by a child suicide bomber whereas engaged on an Australian help challenge in Afghanistan’s Uruzgan province in 2012.

“We did do some good things,” Savage now says. “We managed to get one and a half or maybe two Afghan generations exposed to higher education, then to come to countries like Australia to do postgraduate studies that were intended be the future of Afghanistan. But now, with the Taliban coming back, would you be going back to Afghanistan if you’d just finished your masters or PhD here? I don’t think so.”

Like Poate, Savage is essential of Australia’s “mission creep” and “unclear objectives”, and its blithe willingness to observe Washington into an unwinnable navy useless-finish.

“I don’t think anyone can think anything except what a tragic, wasted opportunity it was for us. We had this massive ability and opportunity to make the place better for the people of Afghanistan … it’s almost like, were we ever there? There’s just a few remnants of bases and buildings. It all looks as if it’s been essentially for nothing,” Savage says.

“I don’t want to sound like I’m bitching because I’m injured … we all know that people are going to get injured and get killed [in war]. You take the risk for the right reason – that good is going to come out of it. But when you realise that the mission itself was essentially set up to fail, it’s pretty clear that people like myself who were sent in at the last minute to try and flood the place with development … in order to keep them happy whilst the ADF withdrew, well that’s not what I signed up for. I was there because I thought I could make a difference and I thought we had a long-term investment to help the people and the country.”

Joel Fitzgibbon, who was defence minister for 18 months to 2009, says he was typically pissed off that navy targets “were confused and vague”.

“The question is whether the US should have stayed out [of Afghanistan]. Because once the US was in, given our alliance commitments, given the importance of the relationship, we were always going to be by their side,” he says.

While he nonetheless values the alliance, he says: “I think we need a more independent foreign policy … we need to demonstrate that we have our own view of the world and we stand independently.”

Sitarah Mohammadi, a former Afghan Hazara refugee and a global legislation pupil, worries for Afghan girls who probably face renewed oppression, and for the persecuted Hazaras, who worry a return of the systemic persecution they’ve endured for generations.

“Australia, and indeed international forces went into Afghanistan in an attempt to topple the Taliban regime, to secure democracy and to so-called rebuild the country. But none of those have been achieved. We wanted peace, yet international forces are leaving Afghanistan in the worst situation it’s ever been in.

“Security is deteriorating day by day, the strides of the last two decades are at great risk, and peace remains ever so elusive.”

JourneyGuides – ‘A tragic and wasted opportunity’: Australia’s inglorious exit from Afghanistan | Australian foreign policy


Travel Guides

Travel Guides Buzz has breaking travel news, travel hotels, America travel guides, travel photos, latest travel news, Asia travel guides, Europe travel guides, Australia travel guides and all the trending buzz you’ll want to share with your friends. Copyright Travel Guides Buzz.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Back to top button