Brooklyn Bridge
My New York commute takes lower than 25 minutes, however skirts the broad outlines of virtually 250 years of American historical past.
I take the ferry that crosses the mouth of the East River, the churning waters by which George Washington as soon as evacuated some 9,000 troops proper beneath the noses of the British redcoats – an escape that proved pivotal to the end result of the Revolutionary War.
On the port aspect, I can peer throughout to the Statue of Liberty, that beacon of hope for tens of millions of latest immigrants. On the starboard aspect are the skyscrapers of Manhattan, these emblems of New World ambition. Towering above me is the Brooklyn Bridge, a feat of engineering from the late nineteenth Century that was the moonshot of its day.
From the ferry terminal in Lower Manhattan, I stroll up Wall Street, passing Federal Hall, the web site the place Washington was inaugurated as America’s first president. Directly throughout from the common’s bronze statue is the New York Stock Exchange, the place the market crashes of 1929 and 2008 posed such a menace to the US capitalist system.
At the prime of Wall Street is the cemetery of Trinity Church, the place one in every of the most storied founding fathers, Alexander Hamilton, is interred. Then I flip proper on to Broadway, with the gothic turrets of what was as soon as the world’s tallest tower, the Woolworth Building, in entrance of me, and the Art Deco halo of the Chrysler Building shimmering in the far distance.
A left takes me into Zuccotti Park, which after the Great Recession grew to become the tent-strewn dwelling of the Occupy Wall Street motion. Then I stroll the ultimate brief stretch to the fringe of what, in pre-pandemic occasions, was a busy however quiet plaza scattered with folks speaking in hushed tones. There, two sq. sunken reflecting swimming pools mark the footprints of the Twin Towers – memorials of recent America’s most terrible day.
Protesters battled police in Wall Street in 2011
Not each American has a lot historical past on their doorstep. But it surrounds them nonetheless. Permeating their lives. Colouring their politics. Determining their relationship to the right here and now.
Story continues
When the pro-Trump mob stormed the US Capitol on January sixth, a few of its members chanted “1776”, believing they had been appearing in the similar insurrectionary spirit as the revolutionaries who overwhelmed the British.
The gun foyer right here regularly invokes the Second Amendment, though it was solely in 2008 that the Supreme Court affirmed the particular person’s constitutional proper to bear arms.
Nostalgic nationalism defined a lot of the attraction of Donald Trump’s ringing slogan Make America Great Again, though he not often specified what halcyon period he was harking again to. That partly defined its genius: voters had been left to conjure up American dreamscapes in the minds.
-
Listen on BBC Sounds, get the podcast or hear on the BBC World Service, or on Radio 4 on Saturdays at 11:30 BST
One of Trump’s ultimate acts as president was to launch the 1776 Report, which sought to overturn what the presidential fee behind it referred to as “the radicalised view of American history”. It was a rejoinder to the 1619 Project from the New York Times, a collection of articles and talks which emphasised the African-American expertise and endurance of white supremacy in the American story. 1619, after all, was the 12 months when 20 enslaved Africans first arrived on these shores.
The Black Lives Matter marketing campaign has its roots in that story, and likewise segregation and the unfinished enterprise of the civil rights period. Many statues memorialising the Confederacy have now been toppled and torn down. Younger Democrats particularly are pushed by a galvanising concept, that historic wrongs want urgently to be righted, particularly when it comes to race.
Gun gross sales have spiked due to fears Biden will tighten legal guidelines
Thus, in trendy-day America, there isn’t a such factor as a bygone period. The battlefields of yesteryear are additionally fight zones of at present. The political geography of America is more and more being formed by a politicised historiography. The past is seen by a partisan prism.
Polling performed by the American Historical Association has proven, as an illustration, that Democrats consider that individuals of color and ladies don’t obtain ample consideration.
Republicans suppose that the navy, spiritual teams and the Founding Fathers have been uncared for. And at the root of those conflicting views lies a elementary divide. Republicans overwhelmingly consider that American historical past ought to be celebrated, whereas Democrats suppose that historical past has to be reckoned with and atoned for.
Conservatives accuse liberals of selling what they name a woke interpretation, heavy on self-flagellation and lightweight on self-congratulation. Liberals typically dismiss conservative takes as chest-thumping cartoons or out-dated motion pictures, like Gone with the Wind.
Rather than agreeing on a collective nationwide story, the pattern has been in direction of separate narratives. Black History Month. LGBT History Month. Italian-American History Month. Native-American Heritage Month. History has turn out to be hyphenated. But it is also extra full. And it is now not written solely by the winners. Marginalised voices are telling tales that want to be heard.
In a rustic the place the nationwide dialog has turn out to be so binary and simplistic, advanced narratives have additionally turn out to be more durable to convey. But it is the very contradictions of the American story that assist us make extra sense of it.
Read extra from Nick
The hand that penned the Declaration of Independence, with its daring assertion that each one males are created equal, additionally authored a scientific defence of white supremacy. Abraham Lincoln referred to as for the emancipation of slaves however didn’t consider in racial equality. The navy that helped defeat fascism throughout World War II was segregated by race. A nation that likes to consider itself as being a metropolis on a hill has typically adopted a bunker mentality.
But even when this historical past does not lend itself to straightforward celebration, does that imply it ought to be cancelled or erased? A San Francisco training board not too long ago voted to rename 44 colleges, together with these honouring George Washington and Abraham Lincoln. A committee advising the mayor of the District of Columbia really helpful the renaming of dozens of parks, buildings and colleges, stripping them of the names of seven presidents, together with Thomas Jefferson and even Washington himself.
One of the driving concepts on the left proper now is presentism: the notion that figures from the past can legitimately be judged by modern mores and values. So the Founding Fathers are forged much less as architects of the new Republic, and extra as slaveholders and white oppressors.
One of the extra cerebral concepts on the proper, in contrast, is originalism: the perception which you can solely make sense of America’s foundational doc in the event you perceive the intentions of its authors at the time it was adopted. Its basically saying 18th Century historical past ought to be our trendy-day information.
The contextualisation of memorials gives one thing of a center floor, but it surely’s arduous to attain any contextual consensus. Should the Lincoln Memorial include a spoiler alert? Should schoolchildren be taught to query the very title of the nation’s capital?
Even Abraham Lincoln, memorialised on Washington’s National Mall, has turn out to be a contested historic determine
US historical past is so fiercely contested as a result of a lot of it’s unresolved. Issues that divided the Founding Fathers are nonetheless up for debate. How far ought to the federal authorities encroach into the on a regular basis lives of Americans? How ought to energy be divided between the three branches of presidency? Should small states have the similar variety of senators as the most populous? Should residents of Washington DC have illustration in addition to taxation?
As for historic occasions that have a tendency to bind the nation collectively, they’re typically based on really feel-good myths. Thanksgiving is a living proof. The story of the Pilgrims fortunately breaking bread with Native Americans quickly after crossing the Atlantic has promoted the notion that indigenous folks gladly welcomed European outsiders to these shores. It ignores the murderous brutality of white settlement and the invasion of place of birth.
Historical amnesia is one more downside: the banishment of inconvenient recollections. The internment of Asian Americans at the begin of World War Two is usually swept beneath the carpet, partly as a result of it is a blot on the file of Franklin Delano Roosevelt, a liberal icon. The Tulsa bloodbath has typically been ignored. For many supporters of Donald Trump, it is as if January sixth, the storming of the US Capitol, by no means occurred.
And then there’s pretend historical past – the intentionally fictitious and fraudulent narratives supposed to mould another actuality. A majority of Republicans, for instance, nonetheless inform pollsters they consider that Joe Biden one way or the other stole the presidential election, though clearly he didn’t.
Nick’s reporting from the US spans a long time
When I got here to United States as a large-eyed teenager in the mid-Nineteen Eighties, one in every of the issues that seduced me about America was its preoccupation with the future. Almost 4 a long time on, I’m struck by the way it stays captive to its past.
Rather than being cyclic, historical past feels depressingly looping. We carry on revisiting the similar arguments. We carry on going over the similar floor.
“We cannot escape our history.” The phrases of Abraham Lincoln appear much more redolent now than they did at the time of the Civil War. Competing variations of the American past have created antagonistic variations of the American current. It helps clarify why the nation so typically looks like it’s in a state of chilly civil struggle, and why I really feel that I’ve been reporting for thus a few years on two Americas.
I ought to finish by saying that I will not be making my every day commute anymore. Not due to Covid. Thankfully, the metropolis is opening up. Rather it is as a result of I’ll quickly be leaving New York, and likewise the BBC.
For greater than 1 / 4 of a century, I’ve occupied a seat in the stalls of historical past. Thank you for letting me share with you a lot of what I’ve seen.