One of many hardest issues to observe as an empathetic viewer is grief.
Star Trek: Discovery Season 4 Episode 2 unpacks not solely E-book’s despair at seeing his homeworld disintegrate however how the anomaly’s destruction has triggered robust emotions in Tilly, Adira, and Stamets stemming from their previous traumas.
What lifts the narrative out of the possibly dismal spiral of darkness is how every character manages to make strides ahead and decide to a future in the direction of which they’ll look ahead.
It is uncommon to see Burnham at such a loss as to what do as when she’s confronted by E-book’s post-anomaly defensiveness.
Chalk it as much as the occasions of her childhood or her Vulcan upbringing, however Burnham’s emotional toolbox holds little subtlety.
She desires to have the ability to face an issue head-on and remedy it with coronary heart and verve and perhaps slightly little bit of luck, none of which goes to chip a speck off of the wall of blame and disgrace and denial that E-book resides behind when Discovery is distributed to gather information on the anomaly.
Hey, E-book. It is simply us now. You and me. And I want you to take heed to me. You could not have saved them. There may be nothing you might have carried out. You could not have recognized.
By the top, she could have launched Discovery’s tether on E-book’s ship, however she stays his tether to the world of the residing.
It is her voice that brings him again. It is her promise to at all times be there for him that permits him to reconnect emotionally once more.
For an individual as empathically gifted as E-book, shutting down within the aftermath of Kwejian’s destruction can be like having all of your limbs chopped off.
There is no technique to work together with the world while you really feel nothing, when all of your feelings are centered on those that have died and who can now not reciprocate.
Y’know, for therefore a few years, I informed myself I did not want household, did not want Kwejian. However then I discovered my brother once more, a nephew I did not even know I had. And after I checked out Leto, I noticed a brand new starting. For all of us. We might give him a future. The place there was a house and household. And love. And nothing he could not do.
Curiously sufficient, I imagine it was Stamets who truly chipped the primary sliver off that impenetrable wall.
Maybe the least empathic particular person on the crew, Stamets has prevented E-book for the reason that dilithium planet for (largely) private causes.
E-book: Ever because you came upon I might run the spore drive, your ego received bruised, and also you blamed me.
Stamets: Nothing to do with it.
E-book: What’s it, then?
Stamets: You remind me of how helpless I used to be. After I take a look at you, all I can see is how shut I received to shedding all the things. You had been the one who saved my household. I wasn’t capable of do something. I hate that feeling.
When he lastly shares the helplessness he felt when solely E-book might save Culber and Adira’s lives on Star Trek: Discovery Season 3 Episode 13, there is a second of readability and recognition on E-book’s face.
E-book’s imaginative and prescient of his nephew and his paralysis when supplied with a plan and alternative to outlive the anomaly are each indicative of survivor’s guilt.
It says so much concerning the energy of his character that he’s ready to withstand the choice of sure dying as a result of he’s dedicated to bringing again the information.
Actually, if the information had transmitted efficiently, it is anybody’s guess if he would’ve taken the opposite path.
Stamets, in flip, makes a vow to make use of the information they had been capable of collect to unravel this anomaly for E-book and to place E-book’s ghosts to relaxation.
Arguably — however I DARE you to argue this level with ME — essentially the most profound dedication made right here is Saru’s supply of himself to be Burnham’s XO.
Extra eloquent than essentially the most romantic marriage proposal, rooted in real respect and friendship, and executed with Doug Jones’s most dulcet tones, Saru’s speech melted my coronary heart like ice cream on Nibiru.
Our mentor, Philippa Georgiou, knew the worth of one other set of trusted eyes, particularly in instances of disaster. I requested you to be these eyes for me after I turned captain. Now, it might be my honor and, certainly, my privilege, to do the identical for you as your Quantity One, if you’ll have me.
Hand to my coronary heart, I’ve by no means been extra tempted to shout, “Say YES!” on the display as throughout that beat when Burnham takes his hand.
Saru’s return to Discovery is seamless. Whereas they acknowledge that he is been gone, he steps into the position of XO like he is at all times held it. And, perhaps since all of us subconsciously knew that Burnham was at all times going to finish up as captain, he did.
In the meantime, Grey seeing his synth physique for the primary time is the follow-through of Culber’s promise to him on the dilithium planet that he would carry him again.
The within joke of referring to Picard as “some Starfleet admiral” is the cutesiest the sequence has ever been about canon.
It does drive house the truth that the Discovery, by touring up to now sooner or later from the place they had been, utterly o’er-leaped the eras of Kirk, Picard, Sisko, and Janeway.
Most likely a great truth to be reminded of sometimes.
Once more seeding momentum with trauma, Adira confiding their fears to Grey lends itself to nice hope shifting ahead.
I think Grey’s incorporation could trigger extra insecurities for Adira after they lose the exclusivity of Grey’s companionship. Nonetheless, I am hoping there may even be great developments within the household dynamic because of it.
Issues simply do not feel the identical manner that they used to. One thing’s off, or I am off.
Tilly’s been carrying plenty of baggage from her Osyraa encounter. Whereas I beloved her reconnection with Saru upon his return and her moments of sharing with Burnham, it is vastly optimistic that she’s prepared to speak to Culber now.
In a current roundtable interview, Wilson Cruz talked about that Culber takes on the twin position of medical officer and counselor this season and referred to as it a “heavy raise.”
With what the crew of Discovery has gone by means of, even simply since they landed sooner or later, his remedy sofa could also be totally booked quickly sufficient.
Whereas the preliminary anomaly information evaluation does not appear hopeful, there’s plenty of season to go.
Additionally, I am desperate to see how the Federation is rebuilding whereas the anomaly wreaks havoc on the universe. The politics — particularly the machinations of the brand new president, Lara Rillick — and the playbook have modified dramatically.
I wish to return to the Trill homeworld and see how Adira’s profitable internet hosting of Tal has modified their tradition.
The theme of dedication extends past the intention of the crew and Federation on the present.
Paramount+ demonstrates — with the assets and expertise they’re prepared to interact — a dedication to flying Discovery so far as she’ll go at a degree of high quality that’ll proceed to set a excessive commonplace for all the franchise.
How did this primary anomaly endeavor strike you?
The place do they go subsequent with the information?
How about these moments of gravitational distortion? Did they only up the sport from the area station gravity shenanigans from Star Trek: Discovery Season 4 Episode 1?
Fly your ideas into the feedback!
Diana Keng is a workers author for TV Fanatic. Comply with her on Twitter.