It’s the proper setting for a whodunnit thriller.
In an enormous derelict warehouse in the dirty docklands space of Cleveland, Ohio, I’m watching crime scene reconstruction knowledgeable Scott Roder spray blood throughout a duplicate of a Sydney toilet.
Earlier he tried to hack by a blood-engorged reproduction human wrist with a security razor.
I do know the blood isn’t actual, however each time Scott spurts one other spray of mock arterial blood throughout this toilet reconstruction, explaining his evaluation of what he believes occurred, it’s laborious to keep away from considering how terribly the younger girl on the centre of this tragedy will need to have suffered, a painful and lonely death 15,000 kilometres again house in Australia 11 years in the past.
Months in the past, I informed Roder about one of my most vexing crime scene mysteries – the death of younger mom Nadine Haag, discovered lifeless in the bathe cupboard of her Castle Hill residence in north-west Sydney on December 4, 2009.
So a lot concerning the case didn’t make sense, I informed him.
Early on, NSW Police declared her death was suicide, however her household was equally satisfied she was murdered.
Nadine was a stupendous, match and wholesome younger girl with no historical past of psychological sickness and there was no suggestion she had any purpose to take her personal life.
In reality, she had an amazing deal to dwell for, particularly a stupendous child daughter.
Scott Roder is one of the world’s foremost consultants in crime scene reconstruction and forensic evaluation, consulting in 1,500 instances since 2001.
His Evidence Room workforce, together with medical director Patrick Mooney and CGI animator Penny Riley, have reconstructed and investigated some of essentially the most high-profile crimes in America.
Roder not too long ago featured prominently in American media protection of the George Floyd homicide case; his stunning animation graphically demonstrated how police officer Derek Chauvin used extreme power to restrain Floyd by kneeling on his neck throughout an arrest.
A jury unanimously discovered Chauvin responsible on all three fees: second-degree homicide, third-degree homicide and manslaughter.
With the permission of Nadine Haag’s household and authorized workforce, Scott has reviewed the evidence from the NSW Police investigation and subsequent Coronial listening to into her mysterious death.
Even earlier than I got here to the US, it was clear to me that Roder had change into intrigued with the Nadine Haag case.
He had referred to as and messaged me, usually incredulous at his newest discovery or bewildered at some important piece of evidence he believes the police missed.
Finally, in an enormous warehouse that appears prefer it may even have been the scene of a grisly crime, he’s lastly exhibiting me what he has found – new evidence that he’s adamant factors overwhelmingly to at least one conclusion: that Nadine Haag was murdered.
For NSW Police, the cursory preliminary investigation into this case declared her death was an open and shut case of suicide.
In 2009, Nadine Haag – a match, wholesome 33-year-old girl in a protracted and bitter custody dispute together with her former companion, had apparently taken her personal life by slitting her wrist in the bathe of her Sydney flat, forsaking a farewell notice and a daughter and household she adored.
But there was extra to this case than appeared at first blush.
According to Nadine’s grief-stricken household and docs who had seen her in the months main as much as her death, she was wanting ahead to a brilliant future and was not deemed a suicide threat.
Refusing to simply accept the inconsistencies in the police evidence and on the crime scene, Nadine’s household engaged counsel to struggle for a coronial enquiry into the chance that removed from taking her personal life, she had been murdered.
We labored for months with the Haag household, retracing the path of the flawed authentic police investigation, and piecing collectively the circumstantial jigsaw puzzle main as much as, and following Nadine’s death.
The household’s re-examination of the case led to the uncovering of beforehand missed evidence and questioned the veracity of the alleged suicide notice which learn, ‘he did it.’.
The Sunday Night investigation additionally raised appreciable doubts as to the adequacy and competency of the unique police investigation.
The household’s persistence lastly paid off.
In August 2013, the coroner subsequently over-ruled the police suicide discovering and returned an open discovering as to the trigger of her death.
Deputy State Coroner Paul MacMahon discovered that Nadine’s former companion had lied to police and that his evidence, “gave rise to real suspicion as to the possibility of his involvement in Nadine’s death.”
But the Coroner additionally declared, “the circumstances of Nadine’s death are therefore a mystery.
“On the one hand, at the time of her death, there was nothing to suggest that she would act to end her life whilst on the other hand on the evidence available there are serious difficulties in characterizing her death as a homicide.”
As a consequence, in September 2013, NSW Police issued an announcement emphasising the Coroner had additionally stated he was happy that the evidence disclosed that the, “…possibility of Nadine’s death being self-inflicted is a real one… [and that] it would not be possible to establish, beyond reasonable doubt, that a known person has caused Nadine’s death.”
It introduced the NSW Police Force’s Homicide Squad would evaluation the findings of the Deputy Coroner.
But the assertion didn’t encourage hope that police would significantly take into account the chance that there was certainly foul play behind the case.
Over a decade later, Nadine’s household, particularly her siblings, nonetheless vigorously dispute the chance their beloved sister dedicated suicide.
They stay satisfied that somebody must reply for his or her sister’s death – that it was homicide.
The household has met over time with NSW Police detectives supervising ongoing investigations into the case, however no individual has but been charged with any offence.
For the Haag household, forensic knowledgeable Scott Roder’s willingness to research Nadine’s death was a new alternative to check with one of the world’s high forensics consultants their perception that the evidence in reality prompt this was a homicide.
Nadine’s physique was discovered underneath chilly working water in the bathe of her Castle Hill residence the day after she was final seen alive in 2009.
Near her was a security razor with the decrease plastic guard eliminated.
There was a gaping wound in her wrist, the clear implication being that she had used the tiny security razor blade to hack proper by the tendons, muscle groups, arteries and veins in her wrist to finish her life.
A notice left close by learn in half, ‘…never stop loving, never stop living, ever stop….I love you all’.
Nadine’s household don’t imagine the notice was a suicide notice in any respect; they imagine she was pressured to jot down underneath horrible duress, figuring out she was going to die.
The notice was her farewell to these she cherished.
Before I got here to Cleveland, Scott Roder informed me he was shocked on the failure of authorities to do even fundamental forensic investigations of the scene earlier than declaring it a suicide.
There had been no fingerprints or DNA collected on the scene, nor was there any luminol testing performed to see if there was any blood residue elsewhere in the lavatory.
This was a chief concern Roder raised with me – one of the evident holes he noticed in the evidence: that if Nadine really had minimize her personal wrist to finish her life, then there ought to have been huge quantities of arterial blood sprayed throughout the lavatory and bathe cavity the place she died.
Instead, there have been only some small droplets and what appeared like a switch stain on the entrance to the bathe.
Luminol reacts with the iron in blood hemoglobin, permitting hint quantities of blood residue to point out up; even when a assassin had cleaned up the scene, a fast take a look at with luminol would have fluoresced if there was foul play.
If solely such a fundamental forensic take a look at had been performed on the time.
The problem for Roder was whether or not he may attain any conclusions primarily based on the restricted evidence accessible from the 2009 crime scene information.
A key query for Roder was what the lavatory ought to have appeared like if Nadine had really minimize her personal wrist in the way prompt by the crime scene pictures taken by NSW Police.
Another main question was whether or not it was even believable that such a tiny razor may conceivably have been used to chop so deeply into Nadine’s wrist.
The wound was such a big gaping minimize that it appeared implausible to each of us that even an emotionally distressed girl may have endured the ache for lengthy sufficient to repeatedly drag such a small blade throughout her personal wrist to chop down so deeply.
These had been the questions Roder determined may solely now be answered with bodily experiments.
So, on a cold and suitably bleak and cloudy day in downtown Cleveland we arrange Roder’s experiments.
The first was a desk arrange with pig’s legs to duplicate a human wrist.
Roder and his colleague Patrick Mooney insert synthetic blood vessels into the reproduction wrist to simulate blood underneath stress in a human artery, stitching the tube into place.
The pig’s legs are clearly not a human wrist, however they appear gruesomely lifelike, identical to a younger girl’s arm.
Then, as our cameras roll, Scott makes an attempt to duplicate the terribly deep cuts to the wrist seen on Nadine’s crime scene pictures, repeatedly dragging the uncovered tiny size of blade on the sting of the razor throughout the open wound.
Time and time once more, he rubs the blade in opposition to the flesh, tendon and blood vessels in the wound and repeatedly he’s pissed off in his efforts.
After quite a few makes an attempt, it’s clear the minute razor blade was totally incapable of inflicting such an enormous gaping wound.
Only after Scott makes use of a heavy bladed knife, making use of his weight on to the wrist with full power, is he in a position to inflict an equal wound.
“Clearly, one could not use a razor blade to make that cut on oneself – that is perfectly clear to me,” Roder declares as he stands over the now ghoulishly bloody desk experiment.
“It’s too painful and the angle that you had to cut at would require you to apply force that you really don’t have if you’re doing it to yourself.”
He concludes that it was very probably another person in the room with Nadine had used a further weapon, in all probability a pointy knife.
Intriguingly, one of the discoveries made by Nadine’s household once they searched her residence was that serrated steak knives had been certainly lacking from a set in her cabinets.
Also lacking had been a number of towels and the costume that Nadine was seen sporting on the final morning she was seen alive.
If somebody did certainly homicide Nadine utilizing these lacking knives after which cleaned up the scene utilizing the lacking towels, that will surely clarify their absence.
The second experiment takes place in a duplicate of Nadine’s toilet, the place she was discovered.
Roder’s evaluation of the crime scene pictures taken by police reveals there was a switch sample stain of blood on the doorway edge of the bathe stall.
He additionally notes ‘gravity droplets’ of blood on the ground.
He suggests these stains are extra in line with Nadine’s unconscious physique being lifted from the lavatory flooring the place she was murdered and lifted into the bathe stall to make it seem like a suicide.
And there was yet one more essential evident problem with the blood evidence – the dearth of it.
“The amount of blood that was documented at the scene was miniscule,” Roder tells 7NEWS Spotlight.
“When you cut your wrist, especially the artery…you’re going to have high-velocity arterial spray…because your heart is beating and the wrist is cut to such a level that it’s not just going to bleed a little bit.
“It’s going to continue bleeding and continue spurting until the heart stops.”
Roder believes that any cheap police investigator ought to have realised that, with Nadine having suffered such an enormous gaping wound in her wrist and the sheer lack of blood in the lavatory space, it prompt another person was there and cleaned it up.
To make his level, he sprays blood across the toilet, exhibiting how a spurting open artery would, in actuality, have left the lavatory awash with blood.
When you see simply how a lot blood ought to have been in the room to match such an enormous wound, one has to noticeably query why the police investigation so rapidly determined this was a suicide; the evidence is overwhelming that somebody cleaned up the scene.
Scott Roder additionally picks up one other element missed by the police investigation, an egg-shaped burn mark on Nadine’s physique that had misplaced all its overlaying pores and skin.
From his expertise overlaying related crimes, Roder recognises this was not a carpet or friction burn; it was attributable to warmth.
He theorises that from the place Nadine’s physique was discovered in the bathe stall, somebody, in all probability the assassin, had turned on the recent faucet whereas Nadine was nonetheless alive however unconscious in the bathe stall.
The savage burn seems on the level of Nadine’s shoulder the place the recent water would have hit. Perhaps the assassin thought that utilizing scorching water would encourage Nadine to bleed out sooner, however it additionally left a particular burn mark.
“The appearance of the wound is perfectly symmetrical,” Roder says, “and that can only be done with water.”
He says that, even on the regular temperature of a scorching bathe faucet, a full burn just like the one on Nadine’s physique could possibly be left by such working scorching water in about ten to fifteen seconds.
Roder theorises that the killer realised their mistake and turned off the recent faucet, as a substitute leaving the chilly faucet working, because it was discovered by the fireplace crew subsequent day.
“The evidence of a full thickness, hot water, burn means that the killer turned the hot water on, I would assume, in his mind, to allow for more blood to flow, to accelerate death,” Roder says.
“But then realised, after the fact, that that hot water is burning her flesh and that doesn’t look like suicide so quickly turn off the hot water, turn on the cold water, and leave.
“That’s what happened, I’m absolutely certain of it.”
Eleven years on from Nadine Haag’s death, the experiments Scott Roder carried out in Cleveland counsel overwhelmingly that Nadine Haag was murdered – that somebody made her death seem like a suicide and cleaned up the crime scene.
This new evidence can be offered to NSW Police, and Scott Roder of Evidence Room has informed 7NEWS Spotlight he can be completely satisfied to testify about his conclusions at any legal trial ought to a identified individual be charged together with her homicide.
Watch 7NEWS Spotlight: Murder She Wrote streaming at no cost on 7plus.
If this story has raised issues for you, contact the Domestic Violence Helpline on 1800 737 732. If you need assistance in a disaster, name Lifeline on 13 11 14. For additional info, contact Beyond Blue on 1300224636 or speak to your GP, native well being skilled or somebody you belief.
Latest Travel News